Classify These Great German Thinkers

[JMack]

Afther thousands of degenerate threads classifying celebrities and irrelevant people, sometimes it's good to classify people who really matter in this world.

I think that only 4 types of classification are valid inside the Caucasoid race in a broad sense (Nordic, Alpine, Dinaric and Mediterranean). This set seems to be a good blend of all these 4 types.



Max Weber

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-cO-D1qP4Q0o/UYBc3XsiFlI/AAAAAAAAFcg/ROrrUU4cRf4/s1600/Weber.PNG

http://thephilosophersmail.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/maxmariane.jpg

http://admsemsegredos.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/max-weber.jpg


Martin Heidegger

http://cultura.culturamix.com/blog/wp-content/gallery/heidegger-martin-1/heidegger-martin-1.jpg

http://filovida.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/heil.jpg

http://www.heideggercircle.org/mh.jpg


Carl Jung

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/00/CGJung.jpg/220px-CGJung.jpg

https://www.jung.org/Resources/Pictures/jung.jpg

http://www.nautis.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Carl-Jung-Headshot.jpg


Rainer Maria Rilke

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/79/Rainer_Maria_Rilke%2C_1900.jpg

https://www.autostraddle.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/59452_rilke_rainer_maria.gif

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-8QSyHddN46Y/U7HgSbKO2mI/AAAAAAAAPdw/W8QOD7SYpMs/s1600/Rainer+Maria+Rilke+-+German+Photographer+(20th+Century).jpg

[decordoba]

Not easy to classify them:
Max Weber - Alpin - but he was born in Erfurt (Saxon-Thuringian)
Martin Heidegger - Celtic Nordid - Northern French/West German
Carl Gustav Jung - Hallstatt Nordid - Southwest German,
Rainer Maria Rilke is not German - Czech + Jewish not sure; I have no idea to classify him.

[JMack]

My Classifications:

Weber: Nordo-Med + minor Alpine

Heidegger: Alpine-Med

Jung: Dinaric + minor Alpine

Rilke: Nordic + Alpine + Mediterranean

[decordoba]

I respect your classification.

But it is no good idea to classify according to the skull only (the shape of the face). It is better to classify according to the vibe of any person, not easy to describe.

A big nose is not only Dinarid, you can find persons with big nose everywhere in Europe, just a part of them is Dinarid.

For example: Luis de Funes - French actor - he was not Dinarid - he was kind of Celtic.
https://fr.igotoworld.com/frontend/webcontent/websites/50/images/news/7793_800x600_Lui-De-Fyunes.jpg

Johanna Mikl Leitner - governor of Lower Austria - she is Dinarid
http://oekastatic.orf.at/static/images/site/oeka/20130939/milei.5186790.jpg

Charles de Gaulle - French president - he was not Dinarid - he was kind of Celtic
http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/charle3.jpg

[JMack]

I respect your classification.

But it is no good idea to classify according to the skull only (the shape of the face). It is better to classify according to the vibe of any person, not easy to describe.


It's a question of methodology. Some people prefer to classify based on ethnic origin , vibe or any other vague term.

I take for myself that only skull measurements and facial shape are valid patterns to classify. That's the reason I think most of these terms like Keltic-Nordid, Baltid, Gracile-Med etc. are clearly not independent subtypes but variations of broader types; these more specyfic terms can have an heuristic value, and I have used them myself sometimes, but they're not reflected on the data.

The only existent sub-types are the 'big four': Nordic, Dinaric, Mediterranean and Alpine. And it's valid for European caucasoids and Non-European caucasoids.

[RN97]

alpine massah rayiss

[Ouistreham]

Martin Heidegger - Celtic Nordid - Northern French/West German.

Let's be serious for a while.
Martin Heidegger has nothing Celtic Nordid nor Northern French.
On the other hand his appearance is quite common in Italy (frequently seen on Ancient Roman statues too).
But if his name was Martino Adecchi, everyone here would classify him as "Armenoid"!


A big nose is not only Dinarid, you can find persons with big nose everywhere in Europe, just a part of them is Dinarid.

For example: Luis de Funes - French actor - he was not Dinarid - he was kind of Celtic.

Quite right, high rooted protruding nose are not necessarily Dinaric.
When combined with a long narrow skull, it often means Baskid" (true Dinarids are extremely brachycephalous).
Louis de Funes for instance, who was not French (he was 100% Spanish).

[Newsboy]

My Classifications:

Weber: Nordo-Med + minor Alpine

Heidegger: Alpine-Med

Jung: Dinaric + minor Alpine

Rilke: Nordic + Alpine + Mediterranean

Agreed

[Columella]

From the pics you posted
Max Weber: Mediterranean maybe minor Alpine Somewhat Ian McKellen/John Hurt look. In younger age was fatter and showed more the the Alpinoid traits like the thick foreheadI guess could pass for Frenchman too
Heiddegger: Noric/Dinaric - Alpine
Jung: Mainly Nordic - Alpinoid elements (jaw?) may apply. A classic Germanic type
Rilke: arrow faced. Some Dinaric/Dinaromorphism well dominant. The rest, entering Coon 1939 territory could be an unlikely "Danubian" Nordo Mediterranoid .

[Not a Cop]

Not easy to classify them:
Carl Gustav Jung - Hallstatt Nordid - Southwest German,

:)

[Grab the Gauge]

Not easy to classify them:
Max Weber - Alpin - but he was born in Erfurt (Saxon-Thuringian)
Martin Heidegger - Celtic Nordid - Northern French/West German
Carl Gustav Jung - Hallstatt Nordid - Southwest German,
Rainer Maria Rilke is not German - Czech + Jewish not sure; I have no idea to classify him.

LOL @ Jung as a Halstatt Nordic, when he was a wide-faced giant.


https://www.psychologistworld.com/images/articles/a/575x360-v-pd-freud-jung.jpg


http://www.crystalinks.com/jungredbook1a.jpg


No, see that's a Brunn. And don't you forget it

[Columella]

LOL @ Jung as a Halstatt Nordic, when he was a wide-faced giant
No, see that's a Brunn¡ you stupid faggot. And don't you forget it

Question: how does Brunn compare to the Dalarna/Phalian types of German authors?

[Odin]

1. Med + Alpinid.
2. Dinarid + Alpinid.
3. Alpine + Dinarid + CM
4. Alpine-Med.

[Amud]

1. Gracile Mediterranean + Negroid
2. Dinaric + UP
3. Dinaric + UP
4. Gracile Mediterannean + Negroid

[Sacrificed Ram]

LOL @ Jung as a Halstatt Nordic


LOL @ Jung as a german, he was swiss (but ethnic german).

[JMack]

LOL @ Jung as a german, he was swiss (but ethnic german).

You answered your own question.

If he is ethnic German he is German.

[Sacrificed Ram]

You answered your own question.

If he is ethnic German he is German.

I know a lot of ethnic german with brazilian citizenship (they are not eligible for bundesbürger because their ancestors spended more than 20 year out of Germany).

[decordoba]

An example of Dinarid phenotype in German population ;)

https://img.shz.de/img/holsteinischer-courier/crop15845411/1216399687-cv16_9-w596/23-85967686-23-85965067-1484496318.jpg

Stefan Andresen and his daughter - Schleswig Holstein - Northern Germany - not far from Denmark ;)

[Sacrificed Ram]

An example of Dinarid phenotype in German population ;)

https://img.shz.de/img/holsteinischer-courier/crop15845411/1216399687-cv16_9-w596/23-85967686-23-85965067-1484496318.jpg

Stefan Andresen and his daughter - Schleswig Holstein - Northern Germany - not far from Denmark ;)

No, they are Nordolitorid.
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y227/Liquid_Len/lundraces-map18.jpg

[JMack]

bump

[decordoba]

No, they are Nordolitorid.
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y227/Liquid_Len/lundraces-map18.jpg

This is an interesting theory - never heard of it ;) before

[Sacrificed Ram]

This is an interesting theory - never heard of it ;) before

Not all authors uses litorid and I was not capable to find pics of litorid exemplars in internet.

[decordoba]

If I don't know that the woman #18 and her father are living in Northern Germany, I would classify them as Slavic (Western Slavic - Czechia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Austria...). In Austria we have a large number of persons who look like them, especially in Vienna as a result of immigration during the Austrian Empire.

[Sacrificed Ram]

No, my city in Brazil received austrians (ethnic germans-tyroleans), south germans and nothern italians and this types are common here, should be native there.

Dinarid, Norid, Armenid, Litorid very confuse types.

[JMack]

bump

[decordoba]

You can search for - Litorid race - in google pictures. And you will find "different" phenotypes, but maybe 50 % of them are Dinarid.

In this manner you dont need the term - Litorid - you can classify them Dinarid.

[JMack]

bump