Noise or Indian ancestor?

[Balkantragedy]

Do you score Indian_Medieval as well? What are your genetic groups on MH? no roma? anyway it is just small % not a big deal.

On MH none of the genetic groups are Romani. And I don’t score any Indian groups on ancient. So I’m puzzled. I don’t mind if I have a Roma ancestor, I’m just wondering why none of my dna test results are showing it besides Illustrative/G25.

[majevica]

It's probably just noise related to Iran_N ancestry

[Balkantragedy]

Don't panic. People here have much bigger mental problems. Exemplum, a Germanic supremacist who turns out to be 7 percent Yemeni.

You know whats strange, the simulated coordinated I got from "explore your DNA" or more accurate than the one's I got from Illustrative. My mother is a Slavic macedonian and the Illustrative coordinates always just clump it with Bulgarian or albanian, but the simulated ones had Macedonia show up as a result

[ScandinavianCelt]

I recently took an AncestryDNA and 23&Me test. My results on both were 100% European with regions confined to the Balkans and Eastern Europe. I had no Roma or non-European ethnic groups. I uploaded my ancestry test to IllustrativeDNA, and my Middle Ages for the Balkans group is appearing as such:

39.6% Slavic
37.8 % Balkan
22.2 % Byzantine Anatolia
0.4% Indian Subcontinent

Is the Indian subcontinent result noise level, or legitimate Indian ancestry? The Roma migration was fairly recent, so I don’t see how both major DNA testing companies missed any south Asian, west Asian, or Roma DNA.

Y Haplogroup- I2
Mtdna- H12

Try the MDLP k10c calc if you can (should be free if you don't have a subscription): https://www.dnagenics.com/ancestry/admixture/mdlpk10c

It will show up as ASI. This calc is ANCIENT, obviously.

This is mine:

DNAGENICS - Admixture Studio
MDLP K10c

Easteurasian 49.05%
Northeuropean 20.32%
CHG 18.78%
Basal 2.55%
ASI 2.34%
Paleosiberian 1.94%
Papuan 1.83%
Siberian 1.21%
SEA 1.20%
African 0.79%

[Far_away]

On MH none of the genetic groups are Romani. And I don’t score any Indian groups on ancient. So I’m puzzled. I don’t mind if I have a Roma ancestor, I’m just wondering why none of my dna test results are showing it besides Illustrative/G25.

Only thing i can say Illustrative is very good. It is not shit like mytrueancestry that is for fun. Talking about us, illustrative really show what historically is correct, that we are mixture of Slavs and paleo balkan people(mostly Illyrians) and settlers from Anatolia during Roman time.
The only thing you can do if you don’t trust it is whole genome sequencing. This beats everything and you can be then 100% sure in it.

[Balkantragedy]

Only thing i can say Illustrative is very good. It is not shit like mytrueancestry that is for fun. Talking about us, illustrative really show what historically is correct, that we are mixture of Slavs and paleo balkan people(mostly Illyrians) and settlers from Anatolia during Roman time.
The only thing you can do if you don’t trust it is whole genome sequencing. This beats everything and you can be then 100% sure in it.

But do you think illustrative Modern is more accurate than every single commercial test available? That’s the conundrum I have at the moment. I just don’t see how ancestry, 23, ftdna, and MH would all miss georgian or Indian ancestry, but illustrative didn’t? Additionally, I did simulated coordinates using K36, and it gave me scarily accurate results. G25 basically clumped things into Bulgarian, Serbian, or Albanian, but the simulated coordinates perfectly parsed out my Montenegrin, macedonian, Serbian, and Bulgarian ancestry. I’m just trying to gauge how much I should be trusting G25 compared to all these other ones lol

[Far_away]

But do you think illustrative Modern is more accurate than every single commercial test available? That’s the conundrum I have at the moment. I just don’t see how ancestry, 23, ftdna, and MH would all miss georgian or Indian ancestry, but illustrative didn’t? Additionally, I did simulated coordinates using K36, and it gave me scarily accurate results. G25 basically clumped things into Bulgarian, Serbian, or Albanian, but the simulated coordinates perfectly parsed out my Montenegrin, macedonian, Serbian, and Bulgarian ancestry. I’m just trying to gauge how much I should be trusting G25 compared to all these other ones lol

G25 is just one of tools to help you with finding more about ancestry.if you think its not accurate then find something else, nothing can be 100% right. You have qpADM people say that is way more accurate but i do not know how to use it. Good luck.

For me simulated cords from k36 do not work, they give me very much Greek genetics.

[Kenshiro]

Target: Kenshiro_scaled
Distance: 1.7110% / 0.01711005
49.6 Balkan
24.0 Roman_Anatolia
12.4 Haemus_Mons
9.8 Slavic_Tribes
2.0 Indian_Medieval
1.6 Steppe
0.6 Germanic

[MandM]

Target: MandM
Distance: 0.0164% / 0.01638943
46.8 Haemus_Mons
36.3 Slavic_Tribes
15.2 Roman_Anatolia
1.7 Steppe


Target: MandM
Distance: 0.0173% / 0.01729487
59.5 Balkan
39.3 Slavic
1.2 Turkic